When We Were Magic by Sarah Gailey
There is a whole lot of foul language in When We Were Magic, particularly at the beginning. It is way more than I expect in a YA book. In the middle of a tense situation there’s a couple sex scenes because of course friends are going to want to have sex with each other right when they are worried about getting caught having killed a guy and working on getting rid of him piece by piece. It’s like the book is trying to be too many things at once. The writing is mediocre. The plot is interesting, though. The title is misleading. They weren’t magic, they ARE magic. I assumed the ordeal would cause them to lose their magic or something, but it doesn’t (though it does do things like take away the ability to dream or cry or have freckles on your face, though). Overall I’m just meh about this one. I don’t really recommend it, but some people will enjoy it.
3 (out of 5) Stars
Books Read in 2023: 64
Pages Read in 2023: 20,217